Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Abortion and Religious Freedom

What really makes abortion restrictions immoral is that they violate vital freedoms including freedom of conscience and freedom of religion.

The existence of degrees of im/permissibility of killing makes it clear that in truth we do not accept rules like, “Thou shalt not kill,” in their literal sense. Such overly simplistic formulations leave out important factors and pretend there is an absolute answer where absolutes are usually impossible. In other words, details and circumstances matter in moral judgements.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Christian Morals are Irrelevant to Public Policy

Christian morality (even if there were universal agreement on what it is) is the wrong tool for determining public policy. Many Americans are not Christian, and Christian standards do not apply to them. This is guaranteed by the US Constitution.

So, when I hear that Christian leaders are for or against transgenderism, my first thought is, So what? That’s irrelevant to the question of what rights transgender people ought to have.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Claims, Beliefs, Theories,and Knowledge

Clarity is good for discourse. The problem isn’t with “claims” but with their evidential status. We can critique some claims as “mere assertions,” “bald claims” or “just speculation.” That is typically what’s at issue when people claim (!) claims aren’t evidence. Let’s be precise.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Strange and Dangerous: How to Stop the Wave of Christian Nationalism

Christian Nationalism is closely related to fascism, adopting the same modes of political engagement: occupying the meaning of patriotism; othering and exclusion; threats and violence, starting with the those least able to fight back; and using religious ideas and language to bamboozle ordinary people into supporting policies that are not for their own good or the country’s but rather for the private benefit of a few very powerful people

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Aquinas’s Epic Fail

The Principle of Sufficient Reason says everything has a cause. The “no infinite regress” principle says something does not have a cause. In other words, these two assumptions, besides being unjustified, contradict each other.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Governments and Religious Freedom

Freedom of conscience and freedom of religion are not absolute, but rather can only be exercised when and to the extent that they do not cause unwarranted or uncompensated harms to others.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Are The 10 Commandments Immoral?

The Ten Commandments are an odd thing for Christians to advocate, for several reasons. The first reason is theological: The whole idea of the New Testament is that the new covenant between God and humans erases the previous arrangement—including the Ten Commandments. The second is moral: The Ten Commandments are not all morally good.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Podcasts on Fighting Christian Nationalism

People around the country and around the world are mobilizing to face the threat to democracy and decency posed by Christian Nationalism, and to defend the idea that governments should stay out of the religion business.

Here are some of podcasts I know that are in the fight. If you know others, please mention them in the comments

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

The Golden Rule and Religious Freedom

Knowing that everyone believes what they believe, and that everyone takes it as a harm to be coerced to change their belief, forced to keep those beliefs hidden, or forbidden to act on those beliefs, we should apply the Golden Rule. I do not want anyone else to interfere with my religious beliefs, so I shouldn’t interfere in their religious beliefs either.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

The Power Worshippers, Part 1 — What I’m reading

Katherine Stewart is an investigative journalist and author. Her book, The Power Worshippers: Inside the Dangerous Rise of Religious Nationalism (Bloombury Publishing, 2019) is a great read, though frightening. She details some of the many attempts to impose Christian Nationalism in the USA

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

Santa is Bad for Society

An opinion piece I wrote for the San Diego Union Tribune, published December 21, 2022. I (half-jokingly) argue that Santa is bad for kids, parents, society, and the environment. It is time for the old man to retire. Parents who want to maintain the tradition should teach kids he is just a fictional character for seasonal fun.

Read More
Bill Vanderburgh Bill Vanderburgh

I am glad you are here!

Freedom of religion is under threat—in the United States and around the world—from religious nationalists, religious extremists, theocrats, fascists, and others, including the merely greedy who pursue their own selfish interests by manipulating the masses through religion.

This blog is a small effort to combat religious nationalism and religious extremism, to promote freedom of conscience, and to be a safe haven for like-minded folks who want to think and talk about what it means to be human.

Read More